Wednesday, October 15, 2014

The problem with honesty




If movie, television and books are to be believed, honesty is the most important aspect of any relationship. I certainly thought it was when I got married. People ought to be honest with one another. In our more recent culture, that has been changed to brutally, cruelly honest. In our current estimation of virtue, it seems that we value truth over kindness, compassion and love. I, therefore, found it a bit of an adjustment to find myself in love with a man who didn’t like to share.

At the time, I was quite insecure. I didn’t think I was beautiful or thin enough to be what a man truly wanted and I was worried that soon after getting married, my husband would realize that he could have done better. I had observed the dynamic in several other couples. I knew that it was normal for a man to admit his wife’s faults or even talk about his attraction to other women in front of her. These things, after all, constitute honesty, which is to be valued over all. 

My husband was never honest with me, as I saw it. If we were watching a movie together and I pointed out how beautiful the actress was, he would scoff and make comments such as, “What are you talking about, she looks nothing like you.” I found it endearing, but also frustrating. I knew he was lying to me and that bothered me.

Fourteen years later, I have realized that my husband’s constant insistence that I was perfect, was the greatest gift anyone has ever given me. You see, what he really gave me was the gift of being unsure. He tells me that my rounded curves and extra padding make up, “the most beautiful body in the world.” He tells me I don’t need make up and my hair is gorgeous in a ponytail. He tells me I am as lovely as the day he met me and he adores me more now than then. He tells me every other woman pales in comparison and he will never be worthy of me. Is he truly so deluded? I DON’T KNOW. When I was young, I was certain he was lying out of love for me. But years and years of hearing something can leave you wondering whether or not it’s actually true.

The greatest gift my husband ever gave me was to make it so that I don’t know whether or not he is being honest. Because somewhere in my heart there’s a part of me that whispers, “Maybe he’s telling the truth.” Why is that uncertainly so important? Because the young woman I was at the beginning of this marriage had no idea it was possible to be loved like that. I do.